Enter a name, company, place or keywords to search across this item. Then click "Search" (or hit Enter).
Collection: Directories and Documents > Pamphlets
Twenty-One Mining Company vs. Original Sixteen to One Mine Inc. Brief for Appellee (PH 10-7)(02-01-1917) (49 pages)

Copy the Page Text to the Clipboard

Show the Page Image

Show the Image Page Text


More Information About this Image

Get a Citation for Page or Image - Copy to the Clipboard

Go to the Previous Page (or Left Arrow key)

Go to the Next Page (or Right Arrow key)
Page: of 49

6
is plain that such discretion has not. been abused.
The record clearly shows that plaintiff ’s action was
not contemptuous and not in violation of the spirit
of the injunction. Plaintiff gave notice of its purpose, both to the trial court and to defendant, and,
as has been stated, sought the aid of the trial court
to secure indemnification before resuming work.
Practically, the only question for this court to determine is whether, under the circumstances of this
case, plaintiff is equally bound by the injunction
issued against defendant.
While defendant has specified several errors in its
assignment (Tr. 115-118), they are obviously designed to cover the one situation raised by the denial
of the motion to dissolve the injunction, and they can
all be resolved into the one question which is here
presented for determination, to wit:
Will equity compel plaintiff to cease mining on
the vein in dispute (in workings long in its possesSion and which have never been in the possession of
defendant), without any indemnification against the
damage to be suffered thereby, merely because plaintiff has caused defendant to be restrained, under the
Protection of a heavy bond, from mining ore in said
von at a point remote from plaintiff's workings ?
ee oy oe eel given the protection of a
the issuance of i te fice: Semnae Sree nae by
mining. Can it be ies se “seiratning u rom
because it attempts to fee rauey Hee oleate
suffer identical dama by deck Enepere mut &e by reason of cessation of its.