Enter a name, company, place or keywords to search across this item. Then click "Search" (or hit Enter).

Copy the Page Text to the Clipboard

Show the Page Image

Show the Image Page Text


More Information About this Image

Get a Citation for Page or Image - Copy to the Clipboard

Go to the Previous Page (or Left Arrow key)

Go to the Next Page (or Right Arrow key)
Page: of 6

ye
me
u
lool
RL ALE ALE MG EAT Ny Ne rin tet te eg
a
themselves
PAGE FOUR
PERCENTAGE OF
MINERAL DEPLETION
By J. R. Finlay.
I have been asked a number. of
times to express some opinion as
to the merits of an arbitrary “‘percentage depletion” as against the
present method of calculating a
deduction from income to cover
eter the cost of a mining property as of March 1, 1913, or the
value of a new discovery, but I have
ays refrained from doing so,
be se I could not find adequate
figures of actual results. Even
Jacking these, it always seemed
probable that sooner or later calculations based upon cost in 1913
would have to be abandoned, because that cost would be all accounted for. This has already happened in a good many .properties,
with the result that the owners find
obliged to pay higher
taxes than some competitors whose
original ‘“‘cost’’ or ‘‘value”’ was higher, or else seek the benefit of fresh
“discoveries” under highly technical
rules governing such discovery, or.to
manufacture through virtue of hindsight a higher ‘“‘cost’’ or ‘‘value’’ for
1913. This bald statement of the
ease is enough to show that a sense
of inequality more or less’ baffling
and vexatious pervades the administration of the present law. It is of
course doubtful if any tax-law can
be devised which will be — entirely
free from objections. There are, it
eee dea
Ses eg eC LE i ay HD ORS OP EE SST BH
samaaiaaasenanaaiaaaantial ateanieitinbiais
THE NEVADA CITY NUGGET, CALIFORNIA
that the average mine was good for. not
about that length of time.
It has never seemed to me that
such an expectation was very much;dependence upon a certain tract by
out of the way, although there are!creating a plant upon it and operatplenty of glaring exceptions in the
direction of both shorter and longer:
life. In the case of very short-lived
mines, say ones that will last only
two or three years, an allowance of
33 1-3-per cent. out_of annual re: .
turn would seem to be low untit-wet
remember that the return must be
exceptionally high anyway— say, 50
or 75 per cent a year—or else the
operation will be unprofitable, tax
or no tax; and the deduction would
soon cover the investment. On the
other hand, in cases where there is a
prospect of life much longer than
twenty years, it is worth notice that
mining inevstments seldom remain
unaltered for that length of time;
there is usually a shifting t6-some
new basis by sale or purchase, expansion, the adoption of new processes, or the building of new
plants—all of which call for investments not originally foreseen. These
new investments have the same
right to be made good as the old
ones, and in the course of time new
and old become scrambled together
so that. it is about impossible to
make an intelligible spearation.
It seems to be arguable that the
life of a mine is not really much
longer than that of the plant which
value only when somebody decides
worth anything: it assumes
to mine it and commits himself to
ing a business. Some other tract
with just as much and just as good
coal on it? may lie a thousand
years untouched, and nobody can
tell which will be which.
‘Even metal mines of
merit are —not--normally valued at
much more than the cost of €quipment and working capital. In the
case of copper mines, Mr. Arthur
Notman. estimates that such investLOS ANGELES PEOPLE
nme
cata
TAKE OVER BELL MINE
Sonora, Calif. June 19—Under an
option of purchase, J+ B. Halbert of
Los Angeles and associates have taken over the Bell mine;on Jackass
Hill, one mile west of
average; from Fred Sutton
Philip. Rowe
same
from various
and bonds
contiguous
Tuttletown,
of Sonora and
of Tuttletown. The
interests have alse obtained
other owners leases
on eight claims either
or in close proximity
ments come to some 30c. per pound ‘to the Bell mine, on which there is
’ !
of annual capacity; that is, a mine
like Calumet & Hecla, with an output of 120,000,000 1b. a year,
would cost $36 000,000 to put in
efficient running order, counting the
lands and ore deposits a free gift.
of nature, costing nothing at all.
The present market value of the
company is not much more than
half that figure.
One might argue from such a
statement that mineral discoveries
are not worth much and that thereis a supply of mineral such as will
operates it; when the plant is renewed, either piecemeal or as a
whole, the old mine no longer exists. It is hard to recall a case
seems, two suggestions: (1) to do
away with the provision for depletion altogether, and +(2) to
provision arbitrary and permanent
according to average, not individual,
cases, so that the mining industry as
a whole will pay the ‘required aggregate . of-taxes: Under this arrangement of course, some properties would. pay more, others less,
than at present. Naturally, those
who would pay more’ would be aggrieved and those who would pay
Jess would be gratified. It is hardly
reasonable to expect that an agreement could be’established upon a
basis of near-sighted self-interest;
it. would rather be upon the percep.tion that in the long run equity
and fairness with consequent stability would be more valuable than a
fleeting and insecure advantage to
some and the, disadvantage of
others.
The figures presented by L. H.
Parker, chief of staff, to the Joint
Committee on Internal Revenue
Taxation, seem to throw a strong
and needed light on these points,
such as could come only from the
records of the Treasury Department.
The “ratio of depletion allowed and
net income from property”’ for the
seven years 1922-28 inclusive was
as follows, given in weighted averages for the period: :
Per Cent
Gold and Silver ......-----0--0» 37.
Poti) (331 -) Uae ety eee rr ete 60.5
LOGd And Zine. 2. -c5.-ccciesceccoake 32.5
Ti6t 2 eae 41.2
COR) ese 31.6
BUIpnUY: <5 .c.ic-c.clozcsceeniercewees 45.8
Arithmetical average of all 41.4
Off hand it would seem as if
these figures prove the present system to be inequitable. Iron is almost
exactly at the average, sulphur only
slightly above it, and copper is far
above it—that is, in the amount of
depletion allowed. Coal may belong
in a category by itself, because of
the fact that the mining reserves
can be figured for the other commodities. Lead and zinc and gold
_ and silver have been allowed decidedly less than the average. It is not
this exactly contrary to a reasonable
expectation? These are precisely the
metals in which the «reserves are
the scantiest, which most depend on
continued discovery, and for which
consequently . the depletion allowance should be highest
Moreover, on this showing it
would seem as if the government
would, for the present at least, actually gain by allowing the suggested
flat depletion rate of one-third current income. Though it would -lose
' the prospect of a diminishing allow-. .
anee in the future through the exhaustion of original cost, it would
gain through an immediate lowering
of the allowances. Then there would
‘most likely be a saving in administrative expense and in the . cost of
disputes and delays; all of which
is so obvious as scarcely to need
discussion. .
After all it is not clearthat depletion should be anything more
than the amortization of capital invested. Assuming thata mining ‘investment is entitled to a return of
7 per cent on its capital, an allowance of a further 3% per cent for
amortization, this installment
have an
cent annually,
original capital
would restore the
in about twenty
years. An allowance then of one-.
third current income would assume
Pe ratte
make
to
earning power of 4. per
where this is not so. Take one of
the oldest and best-known mines in
this country, Calumet & Hecla: it
locality, to some extent within tke
same building, even producing about
the same amount of copper, but the
operations ,have been profoundly
changed in all sorts of ways; by
consolidation with allied concerns
through which the capital stock was
changed from 100,000 shares to
2,000,000;by a new system of
transportation by development of
new ores, and by installation of new
plants for milling, smelting, and the
reclamation of old tailings. How
much money thesé changes represent
I do not know, but it must come to
a large fraction of, if it does not
equal or surpass, the capital assets
visible in 1911.
is conducting business in the same The-eapital is depleted whether the
enable it to compete successfully .
with other operations; but if such
an operation is left as originally
established it will lose itscompetitive
power, and in twenty years or so a
change of base of some sort usually
becomes. necessary -or advisable.
ore is exhausted or not.
These considerations have a c¢ertain pertinence in relation. to the
“valuation” as of March 1, 1913.
That date is back now approaching
twenty years. Its bearing upon present-day competition in the mining
business is wholly artificial. Were it
not for the tax law nobody would
ever think of it. To have to consider it, still more to pay out money
because of it, is a vexation, and aconstant temptation to hunt for-some.
pretext . to evade it. It seems rea-}
sonable to believe that depletion on
a percentage basis, like that already
adopted for the petroleum industry,
and by the Dominion of Canada,
accustomed to believe. This has long
been recognized in the case of coal
I have several times been driven to
In other words, the value of @. would prove sounder and more
mine is less a matter of the ore} equitable.
in the ground and more of the: :
plants and of effort to make that NEVADA CITY CLEANERS
ore available than we have been.
concludd thatcoal in the ground is
;
W. H. Osborne
Cleaning, — Pressing, — Repairing
a 600-foot incline shaft,
25 years ago.
vanced at the same time on the 200,
300, 400,
show the main or middle vein, one
of three lédges coursing through the
Bell property; to very in width from
30 to 49 feet and reveal
milling to shipping grades in gold
value.
Two promising ore showings have
up by William McLaughlin of Columbia on his Lucky
Strike property . 11
been opened
sunk over
Short crosscuts ad500 and 600-foot levels
ores from
miles:
‘ shows a three-foot vein which gives
of from $12 to $70 a gold values
ton, Mr. McLaughlin states.
In cleaning out a 275-foot drift
tunnel, extended in the early days,
five
Mr.
vein
12 to is
from $10 to
$300. a ton in gold. For a length of
on his Independence property,
miles northwest of Columbia,
McLaughlin has revealed a
varying in width from
inches and in value
105 feet, the orebody gives averag
values of $50 a ton, he asserts.:
0.
NOTICE
From now on the Colfax Bakery Cal be
e will supply their products to th
Sacramento Street Grocery, Nevad
City, California.
ANGELINI CICOGNI, Prop.
northSan Francisco.
Washington Stage leaves Nevada
City at 6:30 a. m. for Washington
Leaves Washington at 6:30 a. m.
for Nevada Citv _
NATIONAL HOTEL
AND COFFEE SHOP
GOOD. AIR ‘ a3
FRIDAY, JUNE 19, 1931
; meme}
M (0) D E R N Graniteville Stage leaves Nevada
'City at 7 a. m., for Lake.. City,
. North Bloomfield, Moores Flat, and
,Granitevilie. Leaves Graniteville at
i? a. m., for Nevada City.
; Alleghany Stage tfeaves Nevada
City daily, except Sunday at 1:00 p.
Eye, Ear, Nose and Throat§. ,,.° tor Tyler, Columbia Hill, Alle'ghany and Forest. Leaves Forest at
DR: SAWYER . &:2° 2. @., for Nevada City.
: Marysville Auto Stage a
: : 8.00 a. m., for Rough and Ready,
Ott Bldg. Nevada City orga yore Hammonton and Maryaville. Leaves Marysville at 1:00 p.
Hours 2 to 4 m. Connects at Smartsville for
: North San Juan. .
ae Downieville Auto Stage leaves
Nevada City daily at 1 p. m., are
. Leaves Downieville daily at 6 a.
m., arriving in Nevada City in time
. to connect with 10:30 train for
SONSULTING ENGINEER
CIVIL AND MINING ENGINEERING
REGISTERED CIVIL ENGINEER
LICENSED SURVEYOR
Hydraulics — Irrigation — Surveys
Land Classification.
LAST OFFICIAL MAP OF NEVADA
; ; @ wot! :
OO ere ys ae east of that town. In a crosscut tun—
08 ess me , nel, now in 40 feet, a five-foot. Hydraulics —Irrigation — Surveys GOOD WATER
point. Undeveloped mineral lands} jedze has been exposed whieh: yields . : 4 : :
are worthless. They become valu= mn yleles . Office at Residence — Grass Valley, . Meals and R that .
average assays of $12 a ton in 262 Auburn Street ( 00 ms
able only when development reaches Zi ubur . : eo ;
ee ~\gold. In a drift tunnel, now 25° ft.
ae a stage which renders commercial! . : : = please 4
tion can exist only while there in length and located on another :
ed abeeaerates é section of the property, the face Elevation 2250 Feet
i
Broad Street Nevada City 2
THE ROSE LEE
Hair Dressing and Beauty
Work. Famous Adele Miller
Toilet Articles.
ay LOUISE MARTIN
Let Us Serve You Tet uy
tare
: washday
hh
The BEST Gray Hair
is HomeMade
‘o half pint of water add
one ounce bayrum, asmall
box of Barbo Compound
and one-fourth ounce of
glycerine. Any druggist
can put this up or you can
mix it at home at very
little cost. Apply to the
Remedy
hair twice a week un
the desired shade is obIt will gradually darken
hair and make it soft
FINE WATCH REPAIRING
RADIO SERVICE ANP REPAIR
CLARENCE R. GRAY °
520 Coyote St. Phone 15
Work Called for and Deliveres
~ GRASS VALLEY STEAM
LAUNDRY
111 Bennett St. Grass Valley
EDDIE LEONG
Fresh Fruits wend JOY IN EVERY BITE
—
Builders of California—has helped finance
other buildings throughout the state; has invested and
millions in bonds for public works, schools,
city improvements.
* "> And today—with building costs the lowest in 10 years—
Bank of America encourages economically-sound construction. You are cordially invited to discuss with any officer
of this Bank, the financing of a home or any needed project.
RU =1--L ~~ DF RS QO fF C A leek FO] Kk A
of
largest
construction
companies
in California
are depositors
in
Bank of America
e é e bd p
Hat Ly too, is on the job
5OO miles away
“He may never see the rising buildings that help to pay his
: wages. For Harry Smith is one of thousands — in office,
factory, forest, mine and mill — who are essential to every
construction project. .
Fach new building creates income for many men and
industries. A bungalow may require 100 materials and manufactured products; a skyscraper, 1,000 or more.
The vital importance of this industry is by California's
buildin, ‘epee otalling four billion dollars in the past 10 years.
Most of this money was spent for materials and wages.
Indirectly benefiting every family, construction is normally the
livelihood of more than 100,000 men in this state:
d Bank of America has worked shoulder-to-shoulder with these thousands of homes and
underwritten
and state, county and
Bank of America :
National Trust & Savings Association
Vegetables Every mother knows how childish
; 'f appetites long for “something
Satisfy that longing, put a happy
light in the eyes of your children
with plenty of the nsxost wholesome food—PATSY BREAD.
Order your supply from the
Grocer today
KOPP'S BAKERY
Nevada City, Calif.
Patronize Home Industry
All Kinds of Mellons
hc i “Si ie he Sk ihe Ole Si i hc ce lie ie ie le ie ie ie lie
Free Delivery
eo
OO AAR Seeded deodesefespeteteoteseteseatedeeteeoteaetededed
OSCAR E. WINBURN
ATTORNEY AT LAW
Suite 1-2-3 City HALL BLDG.
GRASS VALLEY, CAL.
Phone 47
LEITER'S RADIO SHOP
. HOLBROOK REFRIGERATOR
Lowest Priced Refrigerator on the market. Complete in
your home at $207.50. less extras. Demonstration given
at our place of business. We welcome you at all times.
We also carry Atwater Kent and Clarion Radios.
We demonstrate in your home. Phone 286
a
eo
amas
FIR-TEX SUPER-INSULATION
Defies Heat—Cold—Noise :
The new building Board 14 inch thick. All 4 feet
'@ in width; length: 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12 feet. Do not overlook this wonderful wall board; something different
than you have ever seen.
SIMPLY WONDERFUL
Now our New Year's Stock arriving in car loads
daily. Paint and Oils of all kinds and colors. Corrugate Gale Steel Sheets, Lime,Plaster, Brick, Doors.
and Windows galore. All kinds Cedar Shingles, Composition Roofing and Shingles in all the attractive
colors. New stock of Flooring, Ceiling, Rustics, in
fact everything you need for your new home. Remodeling or repair wood. Our delivery service is the
best. Don't overlook our complete line of House
THE DIAMOND MATEH CO.
Grass Valley
gino oe nena ntapeyapsainb oer ieee armani ee